Logo being designed, need opinions soon.

[Hyperion]

We hired someone on freelancer to design a permanent logo for EmuDevs.

The plan is to get a text banner/logo for our sites with 'EmuDevs' and get an icon-type logo for 'ED'
to use for avatars/profile etc. It will be a few days before we choose the logo we like and I would
like to get the opinion of the members on the site as well as our staff.

We will get mockups from 5 different designers and give whatever feedback to get it changed.

Once I receive the first set of mockups I will send them to staff and then show them
here in this post. They will obviously be watermarked but I would still like a group of
opinions on it.


UPDATE: Here are some mockups:

Please choose what you think is best or if none at all!

 

[Skrbx]

Cool, cant wait to see...

 

[Hyperion]

Main post updated with mockups

 

[BravadoToDeath]

1st is very nice

 

[Kaev]

The first one looks very nice, but i don't like the others.

 

[Foereaper]

They all look bad imo

 

[Hyperion]

I would have to agree with Foe atm.. Doesn't seem like they nailed it.. Pretty much none of them really match our sites eh?
Not much of an Icon based logo either

 

[Black Ace]

I don't know , I kinda like the last one but it is abit hard to read

 

[Vitrex]

4th best for me !!!

 

[ToxicDev]

Love The icon design of #2 but not a fan of the rest of it. #1 was alright text could use a bit more to make it stand out and 4 is okay. But 3 & 5 not too great in my opinion.

 

[Rochet2]

I think the first is alright. Its probably the most clear with an ok logo. Not sure the icon fits the site though, somehow.
The second has too foggy logo.
The third is just text with a font which is hard to read.
Fourth is alright. Im not sure about the icon though, but it makes sense enough.
The fifth has a bad icon, doesnt really show what it means etc. That would maybe be ok if the text would be clear to read xd

I would go with first or fourth if I had to choose.

 

[Hamar]

I wouldn't choose any of them, none of them fit to current web design.

 

[Zero]

http://emudevs.com/mockups/4.jpg in Blue would more suited to the current website imo.

 

[slp13at420]

i like 1,2 n 5

 

[Tommy]

Why did you even bother with these non-imaginative people? :/

 

[Jameyboor]

4 in blue would be good imo

 

[Skrbx]

For me 1st and 5th, can't decide which i like more. Both are awesome!

 

[Hyperion]

Heres a few more they mocked up...

I think I am going to choose a different designer.
These logos are horrible..

 

[Skrbx]

Yes those last look like created by something like "free online logo creator".

 

[Zero]

Yeah, the latest lot aren't the best. Still reckon the 4th original one in blue, or something similar.